Tax Policy Colloquium — Leandra Lederman (April 21)

Leandra Lederman

On Thursday, April 21, Leandra Lederman (Indiana-Bloomington) presented Hold the Mayo: What Respect Should Courts Accord Tax Regulations and Rulings Issued During Litigation? at the NYU Tax Policy Colloquium convened by Daniel Shaviro, NYU School of Law, and Mihir Desai, Harvard Business School. Here is the abstract:

The question of how much deference courts should accord agency interpretations of statutes is a high-profile and important issue that affects both rulemaking and case outcomes. What level of deference should courts accord an agency regulation or other rule that an agency has issued opportunistically, during the course of related litigation? This important question has arisen in numerous cases, including the 2011 U.S. Supreme Court decision in Mayo Foundation for Medical Education and Research v. United States, a case involving a Treasury regulation.

To answer the question, the Article analyzes the law on judicial deference to tax authorities generally, as well as specific to the context of pending litigation. It concludes that deference under the famous case of Chevron U.S.A., Inc. v. Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc. applies to all Treasury regulations issued in accordance with the requirements of the Administrative Procedure Act. It further argues that Revenue Rulings — formal guidance issued by the IRS — should receive deference under Skidmore v. Swift & Co. Following an analysis of the literature and applicable case law, the Article proposes that rulings issued during the controversy receive the applicable level of deference (Chevron or Skidmore), but that the deference inquiry take into account the retroactivity and surprise issues raised by the timing of the agency’s guidance.

The NYU Graduate Tax Program

This Web site contains the latest news about events and happenings at the NYU Graduate Tax Program, the preeminent program of its kind. It is a resource for our students, faculty, alumni and anyone interested in learning more about our program.

Here is a link to the main Graduate Tax Program Web site which contains course information, faculty profiles and more.